So so very cringey.

I’m old and find this show so fascinating. Yes they have vocal fry but the hosts are funny and I enjoy their friendship. The guests are always fun and the conversations are stimulating

I find the hosts charming and a lot of their takes are interesting, but the audio quality is poor and there is a LOT of cross talk/rambling and very little structure. I also am not sure if the hosts are quite old enough to have fully digested the show idk. I just think it can be cleaned up a bit

Just so good

.

pls never stop making this pod, i need it so last forever, rewatch every show about girls in new york PLS

amelia please never stop relating everything to gilmore girls! hoping that’s our next rewatch.

Love listening to these 2 yap about Girls on HBO and now my fave show of all time Broad City! Great research, jokes, and critical convos about our fave NYC Jewesses 💖

I like listening to these Broads who are in the City

This is truly a broad city slayyyyyy 🩷🩷🩷

I love the concept of this show and I wish I could listen to it all the way through, but had to stop after the first 5 episodes because the sound is really uneven. The lady’s voice level is ULTRA loud and the guy’s is low and sometimes jumbled, so you constantly have to adjust headphone volume. I thought this might be only the first episodes, but just had to stop listening halfway through the latest episode for this problem…

Broad City! Nice job making a transition, expanding, etc

Broad City

While it took them a few episodes to hit their stride, they absolutely did!!! They hit the nail on the head and provide excellent banter. As a millennial, Amelia and Even have given the words to why I love to hate and hate to love GIRLS. After all, it’s a Wednesday night baby and I’m alive Update: BROAD CITY !!! Yas kween

Love broad city and love the pod!

So happy they decided to do Broad City next! Truly can’t get enough of these girls! Thank god summer is over and I can get back to me (listening to two New Yorkers talk about millennial tv shows). Broad City foreva !

the vocal fry is so hot and i’m here for it

no one gets these girls like i do, i always have the most fun listening to anything they have to gab about and the fact that they’re gabbing about hbo girls makes it even better!!

This podcast is so fun! It feels like doing bits with my best friends for an hour. Amelia and Evan have such a great rapport, and it’s obvious they really love the show and are great friends. They’ve had awesome guests, too! I think they’re comedians bc they’re both really funny and make me laugh out loud alone on the train! Lol people must think I’m crazy ! I love how they are kinda satirical just like GIRLS is. (Oops, more like was 😭)

For this of us who came of age with Girls, this podcast explores the complex relationships between the characters but also how we’ve grown and changed since x this is girlhood

This podcast is deep-rooted in conversation and honest in respectful thought. Girls is a real show and so is the Girls Rewatch Pod — don’t be a hater, life’s too short. We get to decide, and I decide to really freaking love it! ❤️🦦

Love these two so much!!! Very funny and insightful

Love this podcast! It’s great to listen to people who love Girls as much as me! Favorite episode is the one with Andrew Rannells!

Girls is my comfort show and I love hearing other people opinions and perceptions about the girls I love so much. Evan and Amelia are amazing, I love them and their Brooklyn vocal fry ❤️

as someone who is constantly rewatching HBO Girls, this podcast was needed.

So grateful for this podcast resuscitating this perfect yet underrated show.

I love this podcast! They really get analytical with it in a way that shows real appreciation for the writing of the show but keep it fun and cute. Also I love vocal fry so there!

The tik tok clips bring me to life everytime.

As a longtime fan of Girls, social commentary, and modern comedy… this podcast feels built for me and should be talked about more. The hosts have a delightful knack for satire, perfectly blending humor with sharp insights about the shows characters and plots. Their awareness of pop culture—both from the show’s era and today—adds depth to their discussions, making every episode feel fresh and relevant, and even informative. The rotating guest lineup is always a pleasant surprise, bringing in hilarious and intelligent new perspectives that enrich the conversation and hearing from some of the greatest comedians/voices of our generation. Even members of the cast of Girls. Each guest adds a new layer to the recap, making every episode feel like a special event. If you're a fan of Girls, or just love insightful commentary mixed with wit, this podcast is a must-listen. Highly recommend.

Yassssssss

I’ve been listening / watching this pod since the beginning and it’s so fun to go along with a Girls Rewatch!! Such funny guests too. Love.

gen z is here to tell you we’re all a bit more Hannah than we like to admit. i’m getting schooled, girl

Amelia and Evan are brilliantly goofy and funny, you can tell they love each other and the show. I copy their voices and inflection in the same way parents worried kids were doing with Paris Hilton… thats how you know you’ve made it

10/10 love this podcast I love the way everyone always has a different take or something to add to the conversation. They really try to have empathy for all the characters and talk about the shows dynamic in a funny but very accurate way

Cultural phenomena of the greatest importance. Voice of our generation. The voice of my generation is going to have a vocal fry. So. For comments about their voices… are you joking? It’s a femme woman and a gay man, did you get lost? You could satirical, jealous or just like you came here to troll. Not everything is for you. Someone writing they seem wealthy so they should get a voice coach, are you a grown person bullying them? Stop. Get offline. ❤️🕯️

Thoroughly entertaining, smart, witty, funny, and amazing guests. I love this podcast SO much!

I loved hbo girls when it came out and this podcast is not only nostalgic, its funny and the 2 creators do a amazing job of making a show thats brings hbo girls back to life.

big fan of the focal fry I say “it’s perfect” like Amelia all da time & I wish I had cooler friends who GOT IT. These girls are so fun & make me feel young again. I am getting schooled, girl.

i ❤️vocal fry. if they have no fans, i’m dead.

I tried really hard to like this show because I love Girls. But there’s no structure, they ramble on about things that have nothing to do with the show & they don’t understand the characters. I think they should’ve done more research on the show & what the writers said about the characters before they started this podcast.

I watched this show live in college/early 20s and it was great. The Gen z hosts are funny and I like their takes for the most part tho they make me so thankful that I am not Gen z. Pls tho @ boy host your lisp is insane! From context of him talking about his schooling/upbringing he is clearly wealthy and can afford to see an speech therapist. this is a very easy issue to fix.

This is a funny, lighthearted show! It’s fun! It’s silly! It’s a good time!

I do enjoy this podcast to go with my girls rewatch but it could be a little more organized and I don’t think the male host likes the female host very much. It’s distracting lol he is always making little side comments or undercutting what she says and the whole “OUR podcast “ in the return episode like oh god you know what she meant. I thought it was just me but I saw another review that mentioned it so I know I’m not crazy. If he can get it together and they can slow down and let each other talk more (and the guests) it’d be a smoother listen but overall not bad. I’m also still on season one so hope it gets better.

Was an original Girls watcher and was the age of the characters as this show unfolded. The hosts are too young to talk about this era and the whole “you’d only understand if you live in NYC” is getting very tired. One host hates nearly every character and relates to Marnie (need I say anymore on this?). It’s giving Gen Z Millenial tiktok discourse.

People don’t even know what vocal fry means anymore..they just love to call something vocal fry

I would love to hear a girls recap but I am so distracted by the way the hosts parrot podcasts like seek treatment and straightiolab. I wish this podcast was hosted by different people.

If you have never lived in New York thank you will not understand almost anything they’re talking about. Not a podcast for regular people who like film and TV at all.

If only they’d talk more about the show. All over the place in structure

Clips of this podcast on TikTok ar what inspired me to rewatch Girls, but the poor production quality and professionalism of the hosts are a disappointment. The audio mix is terrible; the hosts and guests are constantly talking over each other at different volumes; and there’s wayyyyy too much meandering filler full of extreme vocal fry.

I love the GIRLS content, but even more than that, Amelia and Evan help this little 25 year old mess, feel less like a mess ❤️ It’s comforting to hear other people my age talk about how weird being 25 is, because lemme tell y'all it’s WEIRD. Anyway keep on keeping on bbys 🫶🏻❤️🫶🏻❤️